Are you welding in a replacement cross-member?
Heh, I was wondering how long it would take someone to call me out on that one
The answer is no, sort of. I couldn't bring myself to spoil the nice clean look I had going on out back by putting a hoop back over the rear fender. I was, however, totally aware that I would be giving up some rigidity back there as a result. Not as badly as some chopper builders do, but enough to make me think about it a lot.
What I did end up doing was to weld a big honkin brace
inside the fender.
This was made with material nearly 1/8" thick, and it ties into the reinforcing washers I added above. Since it doesn't follow the shape of the fender perfectly, there's an ever-so-slight airgap in places, so as a result we have two differentl 3-D shapes interlocked into a sort of truss-designed-by-insane-cavemen.
Total fender thickness at the weld seams approaches 1/4". It's very rigid. In my mechanical fantasies, this combined with the close fitting and large surface area of the bolted connection above, helps offset the loss of the rear frame hoop at least a bit.
While I was at it, I also layed out and built some sheet metal extensions to finish off the front ends of the metal fender section.
I didn't end up doing the additional frame gussets you see here, I decided they wouldn't really add anything, are hidden under the seat, and would mean I'd have to be much more precise with gaps.
In doing so, I also noticed that I could add some little tabs to the front and bolt through those into the frame tabs that the plastic fender snaps into.
This gives me four points of support on the metal section of the fender, which is now much stronger and more rigid than before.
Also welded in some bar stock at the front edge to stiffen up and reinforce it.
BTW,you're seeing all of this buried under a bit of filler and sealer, these pics are actually from later in the project when I was about to paint. I don't have good pics from earlier in the process, sadly.
In this last pic you can also see the little holes that I'll use later to bolt the metal and plastic sections of the fender together using M6 hardware.
All in all I was pleased with how it all came together, since I started out with no plan whatsoever. You may not be able to tell from the pics but I also had to dish the sides of the fender slightly in order to give me nice gaps where the fender passes the frame rails.
In the time I've been driving it since the work was completed, I've not noticed any loose feeling out back, or signs of things flexing where they shouldn't, but it's not like I push this thing in the corners like some of y'all do
mystic_1