I got the three prong flasher. Read this to be sure to get the correct unit: (mine was labeled 31 - , 49 + , and 49a L )
From Bodi in another thread:
Bodi:
This should go in the FAQs somewhere, it keeps coming up.
ALl 2-prong flashers work using the lamp current. There are thermal and electronic types.
The thermal ones have a heater and bimetallic strip thet bends when hot and switches the lamps off. With no power to the lamps, there's no heat so the strip bends back and switches the lamps back on... and the heat on; cycle repeats.
The thermal type will almost always stop working if you install one set of LEDs (ie the rear signals) and leave one set as regular lamps (ie the front marker/signals). Thermal flashers will never work with both front and back LED signal lamps.
Electronic 2-prong flashers use an electronic circuit to control a relay, this gives a more consistent flash rate. They still need fairly high lamp current to operate. They usually work OK if you have one normal lamp and one LED signal. They will not work with both front and back using LED lamps.
3-terminal flashers come in mechanical and electronic types.
There are 2 types of 3-terminal flashers. One type has no ground connection; there is a power terminal, a signal terminal, and a pilot terminal for the dashboard signal indicator. This type is no improvement over the 2-terminal one for LED use, it just has 2 outputs.
The type we want has ground, power, and signal terminals. The power to make it flash is independent of the lamp power draw. Most SOHC4 bikes have a loose green ground wire hanging beside the flasher, this is perfect for connecting a 3-terminal flasher.
Looking at a rack of flashers at your local Pep Boys it's hard to tell which 3-terminal flasher is the right grounded type and which is the other type which will just blow a fuse if you try connecting it with a ground wire. The electronic type is better than the thermal type, it uses less power and has a constant flash rate as it ages.
The easiest way to know you have the right one is to find one with the terminals numbered. These numbers are a JSO or DIN (not sure which) standard, I haven't been able to find a list of what the numbers mean but they are consistent.
You need a flasher with the terminals numbered 31, 49, and 49a. If you see these numbers, you have the right one! Other numbers means it is the wrong type.
The green (ground) wire goes to #31.
The black wire (+12V) goes to #49.
The other wire (to turn signal switch) goes to #49a.
Some flashers have 2 flash speeds, "normal" and "fault". With LED lamps you will get the "fault" rate. This is faster or slower than "normal" but who cares? It will flash and that's what you want. In a car, with all lamps working, it should go at "normal" and if a lamp burns out flash at "fault" and you're supposed to notice that and think "oh man, the flash rate is different and that means a signal lamp has burned out, I better have that fixed right away". Yeah, right.
Some flashers start "off" (when the signal is activated there's no light for a while then it flashes ON), I don't like this at all. If I'm on a highway and want to change lanes, I want the signal light on as soon as I slide the switch over. If I get a flasher that starts "off" I exchange it for another brand or part number that starts "on" (light ON as soon as signal is activated then flashes OFF).
You can also install "LED compensators" and use the stock flasher. These are just load resistors that draw as much power as the normal lamps. This power then lets the thermal flasher work like normal. This is fine if you just like the look of LEDs and don't want to change flashers. The power saving from using LED signals is infinitesmal, they aren't on enough of the time to make any difference to charging or depleting your battery.