If the tape comes off, then you'll run lean, which can really burn up a piston quickly. If the tape gets sucked in, then you might get some poor valve sealing, which could lead to a few issues. I'd come up with a better option (considering the tape won't like the high heat much), or just wait to get a screw that fits.
How was the Fall salmon run last year? I used to hit the beaches in Kenosha a lot when I lived in Champaign, IL. I remember catching some amazing fish on those beaches... a couple lightning strikes too!
Camelman