I have the standard pushbutton. It's a two-hand operation, but I have no problems. If you have the standard Honda lock, it was my understanding that any key would work. Real tight security.
From an ad:
"A New Old Stock Chrome Gas Cap lock for the Honda CB 750 SOHC, CB 550, 550, 400 and 350 4 cylinder and the CB / CL 450 350 and other Hondas of the era. It is in new condition and is a 3 piece unit (it has the lock assembly, mounting screw and special nut for mounting). It replaces the stock thumb latch on the older Honda gas tanks. It has no key (any key will open it, it is not keyed) and has the part number 69789 on the bag."