Finally good some results with the sanding:
Took it down by hand to 80 grit to remove all the scratches from the orbital at 120. Worked my way up to 3000 grit. It looks so much better in person, it has a nice reflection to it, I'm really happy with this.
Now I'm considering doing the same with the hubs but I'm wondering if it's better to just drop it off at the polisher and save myself some time.
The hubs are aluminum correct? Will it act different than this sprocket?