I prefer the brat style or the Wrenchmonkees (a different style), over most cafe bikes.
I dont think I want to know what the OP thinks is nicer. I think maybe the OP does not realize the amount of work required to get a bike so clean looking..
A bikes major use must be considered.
If you dont commute, or ride around town..but mostly go for a spirited rip around corners.. get a cafe..
If you ride to work, and around town, and use for everyday transportation, a brat style or tracker will do just fine..
Build it for what you use it for THE MOST.. I dont buy the gotta have a tourer for confort to do one long ride a year.. why put up with a landBARGE, for everyday riding, when you only need it for 1 or 2 weeks. Better to suffer a few times on a bike, and enjoy it a lot more the majority of the year....jmo..