Nomad, I was in the same boat. The PO of my bike did the same thing...I would have rathered he poured tar than Kreem. Jeezus, what a nightmare. To compound the problem, I was resigned to do the whole POR15 process in our guest bathroom. Wifey wasn't happy. Oh well, better to as forgiveness than permission.
I did the same as you, and the way the POR-strip instructions would have you believe, it would be 20mins and done. Nope. I ended up doing it 4x. The last 3x I poured nuts/wood screws in, and agitated 1x/10mins for about 2hrs. I used all of the POR-strip, so went to Autozone and bought the Aircraft stripper. I would say pretty much the exact same product. On top of that, both become pressurized with agitation. I was also high as a kite off the fumes. I don't have much advise, but if I can do it, I'm pretty sure anyone can.
I would wholeheartedly recommend the POR-15 tank liner though. Very good product. Btw, I see you're in Chapel Hill. I'm over in Durham, but I'm a grad. student over at UNC. Hell of a game last night!!!