I've been using the optima agm sealed batterys in my race car. After they get some age they do not recover well from a full discharge. Even new if they are completely dead you have to jump them to another battery to get a modern charger to start charging them. Many get tossed because they won't take a charge when all they need is a jump.
The one that came in the car was at least 11 years old. There was no date but it was in the car when I bought it, the owner before me didn't buy it and the owner before him didn't think he did because he was an interstate dealer and would have used one of his own. It was mounted to the rear axle of a hardtail dragster for at least 7 years, then in the enclesed trailer, then in my street rod. I finally killed it when the key got left on.