I dont want to beat this to death but, isnt it better that the comstars would have the weight more inboard of the rim too? Spokes being so light n all, the weight on the stockers must be all in the rim and tire.
Yes, it will make a difference. If you have two wheels with the same OD, but one has the weight more towards the hub, then that wheel will have a lower moment of inertia, which means it will spin up and slow down faster (accelerating/braking).
There won't be any noticeable suspension action difference (some exceptions if the wheel experiences side and rotational loading), but you will notice that the wheel with the weight more towards the hub allows the bike to drop into turns more easily. That handling improvement comes from the centrifugal effect of the wheel being decreased due to the lower moment of inertia, which decreases the force required to rotate it about the X and Y axis (turning).
I have a set of these (
http://autobus.cyclingnews.com/tech.php?id=/photos/2006/tech/features/specialized_2007_road/Specialized_Roval_Rapide_Star_wheel) on my road bicycle, and they are rather portly at 1750 grams. I also have a quality set of Ellsworth road wheels that weigh around 1400 grams. The 1750 gram wheels are heavier, but their weight is towards the center. Due to the design, the spoke count is reduced (lower outboard rotating mass), and there is a windage reduction with regards to the churning work that the spokes impart to the passing air. On top of that, the wheel is much stiffer, so more of the force I apply to the pedals is turned into rotating force, as opposed to just flexing the wheel and spokes. Both wheel sets are high quality, and both are in the $1000 price range, but the wheels with the big hub are definitely more responsive. Now, if I was going out to do a lot of climbing, then I'd definitely put the lighter wheels on.
One thing I've never seen mentioned when talking about weight is the relative effect that the stiffness of the wheel has on power transfer. I know this has a BIG effect in cycling, where every watt counts, but how does it stack up on a motorcycle? It seems like the difference would be just as significant.
Camelman