I've continued to soak with PB Blaster and hit it with the hand impact driver off and on for a week now, still no luck getting it to budge. I don't have access to an air impact wrench. This whole episode started with a chain breaking while riding it and it would be hard getting the bike to someone with that tool in this condition. I have some clarifying questions: 1. The impact driver I've got seems to be reversing directions, so after every hit I'm having to take it off and check to make sure it is turning the right direction. I bought it a local auto parts store, so probably not the greatest tool. Sears just opened a store here -- should I go buy a Craftsman impact driver? 2. I'm assuming this is a right hand thread, so I'm turning counterclockwise, correct? 3. I'm very nervous about using a torch to heat the thing up; I've cleaned the area, but there are still traces of grease, PB Blaster, etc and I don't want to start a fire. How clean should things be first? 4. If I do resort to heat, the part I'm trying to turn is inside the splined shaft, so I'm assuming I want to apply heat to the shaft, not the piece I'm trying to turn, right? I've attached a photo in case anyone can look at it and see something I'm obviously doing wrong.