I removed everything, 24 hr dipped the bodies AND all the parts..then used a bread tie to poke all the holes. Once poked, I rinsed them with carb spray and then lots of air from the compressor.
These are PD style carbs, aren't they? Did you yank out the pilot jets and clean them? What is the diameter of the "bread tie" tool you used? If more than 0.016", this will enlarge the pilot jet fuel orifices. Such damage will cause the machine to run richer.
If I recall, you also mentioned the pilot screws had little to no effect. If the pilot jets are still clogged, this is the exact behavior I would expect.
You soaked the accelerator pump diaphragm in carb cleaner? Carb cleaners are seldom agreeable with rubber and plastic parts.
With most carbs, you have to "prove" that each small passageway can flow fluid when disassembled. With pump carbs you also have to "prove" the check valves seal in one direction and flow in the opposite direction.
Imo, if the plugs are sooty, you certainly have enough spark to fire a mixture, but not enough oxygen to complete the fuel burn.
If you peruse enough threads regarding carb cleaning, you'll find it took quite a few 3rd or 5th tries to actually get the
all the carb circuits clean, even though the poster was certain that the carbs were completely clean in their very first post. So, don't overlook the possibility that you missed something unique to these carbs.
Are each cylinder's spark plug deposit patterns the same as all the others? I use this indicator to tell me if the carbs are delivering equally, or if one carb is operating differently.