I've got two 650 cams sitting here and 650 one tach drive and one 650 tach. I gave the bike I was building to my son, and all the parts too of course, on the condition that he finish building it. So I never put it in the bike. When got the first cam (E-Bay) it was bare. So I went looking for a reasonably priced tach drive and tach. I found them on E-Bay too, and got both for another $25 plus a couple of bucks to ship them.
Like you I went out and asked a lot of questions first and also spent about two months looking for comments about them before I finally bought the stuff. Virtually every comment I found about the switch said the same things you are seeing here. That is to say the comments indicated that the cam was indeed a good switch for power production. They were in agreement about it coming on at about 6,000 RPM as well. Like Gordon I too picked up a 16-tooth front sprocket so as to take full advantage of the movement of the power band up; I actually considered a 15-tooth but decided it was likely to be just a little too much.
As for the tach, the one I got is very much different than the stock one and mixing the two would look like unmitigated hell. I gave some thought to trying a 650 speedometer to go along with it but I don't know if the thing will fit in the 550's gauge mount or not. I have had bikes that only had a tach and I've had bikes that only had a speedometer. While I prefer both I can do with either alone. If I was just able to have one I'd take the tach over the speedometer. That said, if I was just going to have a tach I'd probably go hunting for a good looking electronic one and just have a plug machined for the tach drive hole.