Every time you move the plate reset your point gap...something I found out the hard way.
Also, try to increase or decrease the point gap, it has a much greater affect on the timing than moving the plate back and forth.
I found at .014" I couldn't get it set, now I use 0.012" and have lots of adjustment. Maybe you will be the opposite but you have to experiment a bit to see what your bike is happy with.
I use a timing light. Static timing gets you close, but a timing light is excellent to fine tune the timing.
For the $50 you can't go wrong. Run the timing light off a second car battery and connect the ground of the battery to the ground of the bike.