Okay, after so many told me that it would definitely fit, I went out and tried it again. the left side--the side with the disk--rubs. No way it's going to work.
I then took the fender back off and bent it silly and tried to reinstall. Still not fitting.
I shot some high quality images of the tire rubbing the fender's left side, but the files were too big to upload. I'll try to upload what I can.
Also, the fender seems to have been cut in the past--where it clears the brake assembly. You'll see it in the photos if I can upload them.
Finally, I'm including some shots of my front wheel. Is there any possibility I'm missing a spacer? I don't know.