I think it works. I've only done 3 projects and they've been pretty lightweight.
I've done a set of carbs that were still assembled. I taped everything closed and avoided blowing directly into openings. Just focused on the bodies and the throttle linkage. Cleaned them, soaked them, cleaned them. Came out very good for the amount of effort it took.
I tried doing a chain guard but it didn't really have the strength to get the paint off of it. It smoothed out some edges and removed some rust spots but I ended up just doing a little sanding, primer & paint.
Last week I did the rear hub off a 500. Again very pleased with the results. It easily cleaned the yellowed, flaking paint and left a very nice smooth finish. However, the soda was not able to remove the thick gunk that I guess is a couple of decades worth of chain lube. I had to scrape that by hand (came off easily with light scraping) and then finish the job with the soda blaster. Painted it with the leftover VHT aluminum color spray paint I had from another project: 4 coats, 10 minutes between. Finished the hub with new spokes, rim, tube & tire. Pretty proud of that for a first effort.
In doing these 3 projects, I used one 50-lb bag of soda. I'm sure someone more experienced could have done more with less but I'm happy with it. I use my 20-gallon oil-less compressor; it's barely adequate for the job but I'm only doing a small number of items. If I keep going and getting more into this, I'll upgrade to something better.
I'm going to do the front hub tomorrow using the same process. I'll report the results soon. Too hot out there right now; up to 95 already.
Cheers
PS Also remembered that I used it to clean some light rust off the rear brake arm. I'll be doing more investigating about using this for rust removal on hard to reach spots as the opportunities arise.