So I'll go first then:
Punk was given the lovely Air Kong Football on Christmas Eve. With him, if it doesn't get destroyed within the first hour, it will usually last a long while. He was ecstatic as always when he gets a new toy, and he hasn't played with any of his old toys since. Its basically a giant yellow tennis ball football. It also has a very loud squeak. This is actually the only toy he will play fetch with and seems to be a really decent buy.
Price: $6.99~$8.99
Durabilty: 9/10 The tennis ball covering has shown some fatigue/shedding. The ball itself is still solid.
Fun Factor:
For the dog, 10/10, nice loud squeaker that they CANNOT get out. He was actually annoyed at first, nudging it with his nose and barking at it. Eventually he got over it.
For the Owner: 7/10, nice loud, annoying squeaker, the toy gets put away at night. Also, your arm will get tired from throwing it so much.
Overall: 9/10, we'll see how it fairs longterm.