Derek,
I just removed my rotor. My starter hasn't worked for #$%* for quite some time. It would catch, not catch, or catch and release like your's. I expected it was the rollers, springs, and caps like you guys suspected so I bought the complete set. I used my
air impact wrench and
rotor puller tool like you have pictured. GET ONE OF EACH! Piece of cake dude. Hopefully the threads on the tool will work with your 750s also. I was sursprised at what I found when it came off. Expect the unexpected.
First thing I noticed: One of the 3 screws that holds the starter clutch to the rotor had broken! How the hell did that happen!!
The whole starter clutch was loose. Good thing those g#ddamned dimples that we all hate to have to drill out were there or I'd had a mess somewhere on the road. The other 2 screws stayed in place but were loose at the threads. It was just a matter of time before all hell broke loose. Rollers, etc looked good but it never hurts to replace those pieces if you have it apart.
Next thing I noticed was the damage that floating screw head had done to the gear. It wouldn't affect anything however.
I grabbed my 78 K gear to compare. That's when I noticed the surface area where the rollers grab. My original had quite the flat spots worn into it. I didn't really notice this visually but rather when I ran my fingers around the surface. I believe this is an issue also. The 78 gear is in better shape so i'll just use that one. Compare the 2 gears and you can see the damage the screw head did. The surface where the rollers engage can't really be seen in a picture.