the seat may be different, but the tank mounts are the same on an F frame and a K frame. i know--i have two K's and an F in my garage, which have all been in a big orgy of parts swapping. knowing this wouldn't solve the seat-to-tank fit issues, but you could at least swap the tanks without a problem. by the way, I'm also not terribly keen on the trap door style filler, but i think the F tanks look much better overall than the K tanks. they have a tougher broad-shouldered look to them.