Hey Pain...are you planning to stick with 19" diameter front, or switch to 18"?
If you want black rims, does dimpled versus non-dimpled really matter that much?...the black color pretty much kills the "look as true to original as possible" idea.
Let the rim width be dictated by the tire size you plan to run, and keep in mind modern bias ply tires are designed around much wider rim widths than these bikes had originally. For example, the recommended rim width for an Avon AM26 Roadrider in 3.25-19 is 2.15", with allowable range going from 1.85" (stock Honda) up to 2.50". The AM26 rear (universal) 110/90-18 calls for a 2.50" rim, but has an allowabe range of 2.15" to 3.00". A 120/90-18 calls for rims between 2.50" and 3.00.
It it was me, I'd go for 2.15" width front and 2.50" width rear.