You said initially that this was a routine cleaning so I assume it was working reasonably well before. If that is the case, then something is definitely holding it in. I'm not familiar with your specific MBC but there should be just the C clip and then the washer retaining the piston assembly. If the C clip is out but the washer has not fallen out freely, perhaps it is rusted solidly in place. Can you see rust in the recess where the washer rides? Better yet, do you see the washer itself? BTW, how long since the last teardown (that you know of)?