Well so I got into it myself tonight - data: K1, 16"rear.
the existing 16" spoke set i worked off spoke by spoke - a real pain, but i was nervous about getting it back properly so i went s l o w. a few i had to cut out...
thing to know is that ALL of my spokes are innies, that is, they all thread into the holes from the outside of the spoke hub. i guess this must be a 16" mod thing because all of the other bikes in the garage are laced one outie one innie crossing...i looked around and didn't see any others like mine.
anyway the OLD spokes were really high quality. thickened shoulders about 3/8" below the head and instead of bending one of each pair the neck of the one to cross behind is elongated slightly, offsetting it to go behind the first.
the NEW spokes are stainless steel. a touch thinner, or at least without a thickened shoulder or neck below the head. the one to go under is BENT about 1/2" down from the head. this is supposed to allow it to go around behind the first spoke with minimal deflection.
SUPPOSED TO i say because once i had laced them all up and snugged them down i found that the heads of the "top" spoke were being pushed out of their seat by the force of the "bottom" spoke pushing out.
i took them all out.
i did a test lace with a couple using the bent spoke as an outie - that is threading from inside the hub, but this did not work, clearly the method for lacing these 16s is different from a stock tire and since there is no head seat on the interior of the spoke hub i couldn't see a way to make it work.
here i should say that the heads of the NEW set are puny compared with the OLD set. smaller and i can see light coming in around them now that i have the spokes firmed up. this bothers me.
so...i relaced following the original pattern, all innies, but this time after getting all the nuts on (two or three turns) i took the "top", or straight spokes to full seat, leaving the bent, bottom spokes loose.
then i tightened down the bottom spokes. this caused some deflection in the uppers, bowing them slightly out, despite the bend that is supposed to compensate. this is a characteristic that was not present in the OLD set due to the longer necks of the bottom spoke. this bothers me, but i will talk to the guru who is doing the trueing/tire mounting for me tomorrow.
all in all the EASY part was the actual lacing - i could teach a class!
the little discrepancies bug me and the apparent low quality of the spokes bothers me too. these are the sets that you see come up on Ebay all the time, Stainless Steel - it's always the same seller.
i'm not saying they are bad, yet, but i will be a little miffed if the mechanic tells me to pitch the whole lot tomorrow - not to mention i have a potential new gf that is expecting a ride this weekend! i HATE performance anxiety!
i will try to post some pics tommorow of the OLD spokes. i didn't take any (dumb) of the lacing - i loaned my camera to a collegue today, but i have a set of the OLD spokes in my pocket and will post up tomorrow so you guys can analyse the quality with me. despite the corrosion they are wonderful little bits.
any ideas??
junkie out...