OK, so it is/was running rich. I tried an old trick to help lean it out some by removing a few drops of gas considering the gas cap musta had a leaky seal

Besides, I think those few drops of gasoline mighta actually cleaned that pristine carpet.
It was running rich WITHOUT an air cleaner AND going from sea level to 5000 ft. I'd start by lowering the mains 1 size for the altitude and another size for installing an air cleaner which really needs to be done. Performance and mileage will improve.
Does the 650 with CV carbs use the same jets as a 750? Paul, why don't you and Mad Dog drop a float bowl and check out the size of the mains and report back?! We ain't stopping at no stinkin valve adjustment!