follow up:
i just pulled the #1 plug and did a spark check. it appears to be good (as far as i can tell). it was MOSTLY blue with occasional sparks of orange in there. i also drained the #1 carb and there were a few TINY specs of something in there, but nothing that really jumped out at me.
Your spark is probably good enough. The plug may be starting to carbon foul and bleed off some spark energy.
There are still several possibilities.
How old are those plugs?
What is their number?
Do the black deposits feel dry powdery or oily sticky?
You still running the stock air filter?
Does the black spot on #4 scrape off? Or, has the porcelain glassified? Describe that deposit.
Making some assumptions, I may regret later, the plugs seem to indicate the dark one is running richer than the others. IF the compression is even across the cylinders and all the other items on the tuneup checklist are up to new and peak spec, I would guess there is an issue with No. 1 carb.
If it turns out to be the carb(s) here are some possibilities:
Carb Synchronization error
Pilot screw Air bleed setting different from others.
Wrong pilot screw installed in some of the carbs. (some types are hollow, yours s/b solid)
slow jet damaged (enlarged from cleaning orifice with wrong tool)
Slow jet loose.
Main needle set at wrong or different height than other carbs.
Wrong main needle installed or different from other carbs.
Needle jet emulsion tube cross drilled holes clogged (or at least some of them).
Main jet oring leaking or carb body corroded to prevent proper seal of main jet.
Float height setting incorrect.
Float needle and/or seat leaking.
Float needle seat oring leaking.
Main or slow system air jet partially restricted.
When examining fuel drainage, specs larger than .016 inch can clog/block slow jets. A blocked slow jet will frequently give you a cold head pipe and poor idle performance, as cylinders won't fire at all without fuel. I suspect this is Briboy's issue.
Too much fuel (due to some leakage or setting error) in the fuel/air mixture can cool the combustion temps and head pipe, too. Sooty carbon deposits on the spark plug insulators is evidence that the cylinder temps are not high enough to completely burn the fuel, leaving behind unburned hydrocarbon deposits (soot). This is probably 3ntr0py's issue on #1. Not sure about #4, yet.
Cheers,