Just found the thread...Disregard everything I told you!
R1, R2, etc are just casting numbers and mean nothing more. I guess I should have followed up the next day or so. Glad I didn't run and buy any cams thinking they would be worth more money!
http://forums.sohc4.net/index.php?topic=62266.0
I thought the way you did about the early numbers. what we've found in that thread is that at some point (mid-70s) Honda started to repeat the casting numbers.
So I think there is still some truth to the idea that lower numbers are hotter, but only if one is sure they came from an early engine, and its not as linear as I had been led to believe.
So you can have a red hot R1 if it came from an early engine, or a dud R1 if it came from a later engine. And you may have an R3 that's hotter than an R2, again depending on the engine date it came from. That's what i came away from that thread with.
And almost for sure any early cam is hotter than an R9. But you could have an R1-3 that's deader than the R9 if the R1-3 is from a later engine.
One thing is for sure there are hotter cams but the only way to be sure is to measure them. Its obvious to the naked eye if one has a micrometer eye. Mine aren't as good as they used to be.
