This is what I used to replace my leaking oil pump O-ring, 2x46mm 75 durometer 75 Viton, McMaster-Carr # 9263K665. There is also a Buna-N version in the same size, but I recommend the Viton since it has a higher temperature rating, and tends to retain its shape better under pressure to prevent pre-mature compression and leaking. They are sold in packs of ten, which is fine since the cost is low (~$15 per pack) and you end up with lots of spares.