I've used gauges, a mercury filled type, and the carbtune. The gauges are nice: easy to read, easy to calibrate (or at least get all 4 reading the same) but pretty bulky and somewhat delicate. The mercury unit was great but once filled with mercury they can't be stored away easily, I think I left it hanging in the basement of a house I moved out of. Carbtune is certainly adequate and similar to the mercury sticks to read, seems sturdy, and is easy to store. But like my timing light and electronic ignition, I have used it rarely as I haven't had the carbs off many times. Last time was 4 years ago when a fuel crossover O-ring fell apart with predictable fuel dribbles.