Stock bulb is a 50/40 Watt. At 12.8V it draws 3.9A/3.25A. A 9003 Bulb draws 5A/4.58A. It better flocking well be brighter.
http://www.donsbulbs.com/cgi-bin/r/b.pl/9003~lucas.htmlThis bulb will tax the 150 Watt charging system on the CB550, leading to weak battery charge. And, if there is voltage drop in the headlight power circuits, it will be worse with more current drawn through it. Worse, if the Black wire distribution line gets lower voltage, this is also what powers the electromagnet in the alternator. A weaker magnetic field means lower alternator output. (rim shot, please)
When the voltage to the coils drops below 9 or 10 volts, be prepared to curse the darkness and deafening silence. (Or, withstand the curses of other drivers waiting for you to push that " Old POS" out of the traffic path.)
Yes, that new headlight will be brighter for a while. Just don't ever let the the engine run below 3000 RPM. And, always keep the battery on the tender when parked. Just what you need for a convenient reliable street bike.

I still think he should measure the voltage at battery and compare to what the headlight actually receives. This will indicate the bikes electrical system health and its ability to really benefit from a brighter bulb (even if it has the same (or lower) power draw of the old one). IMO
Yes, an old bulb can degrade over time, if the internal reflector components lose their reflectivity. This can be a function of bulb quality. The Honda ones were pretty good, until they were used to bash things.

But, the foibles attributed to "old Bulbs" often are a result of less voltage getting to them. And, that will certainly make them dimmer.
Cheers,