OK, I took the carbs apart AGAIN and cleaned all the airways as much as possible. This time I decided to switch all the internals from carb #4 (Rich cylinder) to carb #1. I don't have a way to check compression at this time. #4 is still rich. I'm thinking about upgrading to the Dyna ignition to get my timing just right and maybe get a bit stronger spark to see if things begin to clear up. Any other ideas?
Did you try moving the float out of #4 and a known-good float from another carb into
the #4 carb?
Another thing you can try, temporarily: switch #4 to a hotter plug and see if it lightens up.
I have another bike I'm working on that came with 107.5 main jets stock from the factory.
They had been drilled out -- to about 155. Didn't find out until I went to the parts counter
to buy a new set of mains -- then discovered they'd been drilled. The only way to tell was --
I compared the inner diameter of my "107.5" with 115s that I wanted to move up to -- and
found the 115s were SMALLER....then I checked 122.5...still smaller than my "107.5".....etc.
(The turkey failed to check the rubber intake boots, which were cracked and leaking, and
in trying to fix his lean problem he must have went to town on the stock 107.5's.)
The problem with drilled-out jets sitting in a mechanic's box of his collection of 'rejetting stuff'
is you can't tell from the label on the jet anymore. One carb might get a drilled-out main jet
-- so maybe do a side-by-side comparison of the inner diameters of your #4 main and the other mains. LONGSHOT? Yep. But a guy who drills jets to save money will also save everything like a packrat after finishing one project bike and possibly mix 'em up by accident on his next project.