too high octane and plugs will be sooty but engine will perform ok until the plugs soot up so bad that they foul. The soot can be burned away by a good hard blast...so full throttle plug chops are gonna look ok, anything less than 3/4 throttle is gonna look rich.
I used to always run 93 in my bikes during the summer time, just for the added detonation protection. Lately, I've been useing 89 or 91 and getting better part throttle performance.
I forgot what your engine build is as far as compression ratio...stock?, 87 to 89 should be fine. Higher compression? you may need 91 or higher.
My advice to you is if you are getting good performance, and plug readings show nothing dangerous, put the damn spark plug wrench away and go for a ride.