I just dressed up a set of comstars that were all gouged up around the bead from ham-fisted P.O.'s tire changes. Standard aluminum polishing steps work well here, just more of it. Start by sanding, something around 200 grit, then 400, then either 600 grit or steel wool, then to the polishing compounds. It's just more sanding than raw aluminum, but the results are just as nice, just more work.